Nurdle in the Rough All articles
Lists & Hot Takes

Thatch, Grubs, and Turn-Based Combat: I Outsourced My Gaming Backlog to a Lawn Care Pamphlet

Nurdle in the Rough
Thatch, Grubs, and Turn-Based Combat: I Outsourced My Gaming Backlog to a Lawn Care Pamphlet

Photo: Huangdan2060, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Pitch, Which I Cannot Legally Blame on Anyone Else

Here's how far my brain has rotted: I was standing in the checkout line at a hardware store, holding a flyer about seasonal lawn maintenance, and I thought, "these would make good game categories."

Not game genres. Game categories. As in, if my lawn needs aeration, I play a game about rebuilding something from the ground up. If it needs grub control, I play something where you hunt down infestations. That's it. That's the whole system. A dartboard of homeownership that picks my entertainment.

I want to be clear that I own a modest patch of St. Augustine grass in Ohio and I have never once successfully kept it alive. The lawn and I have a hostage situation relationship. So this experiment was also, on some level, revenge.

I wrote six terms on index cards, put them in my wife's abandoned pie tin, and spun. Here's what the turf gods demanded of me, and what I found in return.

Spin 1: "Aeration" — Poke Holes in Something Until It Breathes

The logic: aeration means punching little holes in compacted dirt so air and water can get in. My gaming translation: a game about restoring something choked and neglected.

The spinner delivered me to Graveyard Keeper, a game where you inherit a medieval cemetery and must single-handedly un-ruin it while also farming, crafting, and — this is true — morally deciding whether to bury bodies or, ahem, repurpose them.

Verdict: it's aeration in game form. You poke holes in a decrepit operation until things start flowing again. It's also a grind, which is thematically perfect because so is lawn care. I put in about 22 hours, developed genuine feelings for a talking skull, and learned that the automated crafting system is somehow both a blessing and a labrynth. Four mowers out of five.

Spin 2: "Grub Control" — There Are Larvae Under Your Beautiful Life

Grubs, for the lucky uninformed, are beetle larvae that eat your lawn's roots while everything looks fine on top. It's a metaphor so on-the-nose I'm surprised it's not a Plath poem.

Game match: Bug Fables: The Everlasting Sapling. Yes, it's a Paper Mario-style RPG where everyone is a bug. Yes, I chose it because of the word "bug." No, I will not be taking questions, because the joke wrote itself and I merely transcribed.

Here's the thing though: this is the best game I played all month and possibly the most overlooked RPG of its era. The party mechanics are genuinely clever — you swap turn order, use team attacks, and the writing is funnier than it has any right to be. It's on basically every platform now. If you slept on it because it looked like a knockoff, the grubs were eating your roots the whole time. Five mowers.

Spin 3: "Dethatching" — Removing the Dead Layer Everyone Pretends Isn't There

Thatch is the layer of dead grass gunk that builds up between the green stuff and the soil. Dethatching means ripping it out so the lawn can actually live. Aggressive! Therapeutic! Kind of dark!

Game match: Kena: Bridge of Spirits. You play a spirit guide who helps restless souls move on — literally clearing away the dead layer so living things can grow. Also there's a rot creature collection mechanic that is basically cute Lootbugs with faces.

I'll be honest: I bounced off Kena's combat difficulty twice before the spinner's authority carried me through. Third time stuck. The boss fights are the kind that make you mutter "okay, one more" at 1 a.m. on a work night, which is the highest compliment I give. Four mowers, docked one for the boss that shall not be named.

Spin 4: "Overseeding" — Pouring More Onto What You Already Have

Overseeding is throwing new seed on top of an existing lawn to thicken it. My match: Chained Echoes, an RPG that lovingly scatters new ideas on top of classic JRPG soil until the whole thing is thicker and greener than the sum of its inspirations.

Overheat mechanic? Fresh. No random encounters? Refreshing. A sky-island world with mechs AND medieval politics? Sure, why not, the seed bag is bottomless. I sank 35 hours in and only stopped because the spinner demanded more sacrifices.

The Final Ranking of Lawn Chores as Game Curators

  1. Grub Control — Bug Fables. The pun worked and the game slapped.
  2. Dethatching — Kena. Emotionally devastating in a good way.
  3. Overseeding — Chained Echoes. Comfort food with a knife in it.
  4. Aeration — Graveyard Keeper. Great game, I just resent grinding that reminds me of my actual chores.

Closing Arguments

Did the lawn pamphlet system work? Embarrassingly, yes. It forced me off the same three comfort games and into a backlog I'd been ignoring like an HOA violation letter.

The real lesson, though, is that my lawn remains a disaster, my spinner now lives on the kitchen counter, and my wife has started referring to Bug Fables as "the grub game." I've never felt more seen by a pie tin in my life.

All Articles

Related Articles

My Hobbies Were Chosen by Dice for 30 Days and the Dice Have No Respect for Me

My Hobbies Were Chosen by Dice for 30 Days and the Dice Have No Respect for Me

Field Notes From the Nerd Diaspora: A Glossary of Everything I've Said That Made Coworkers Back Away Slowly

Swamp Finds & Sticky Sitks: My Estate Sale Controller Clean-Up Olympics, Ranked by Ick Factor

Swamp Finds & Sticky Sitks: My Estate Sale Controller Clean-Up Olympics, Ranked by Ick Factor